Updated every Monday!   Subscribe to free weekly newsletter.

Walgreens Improperly Charged Sales Tax in Massachusetts — Again

It looks like Walgreens is at it again — charging sales tax on some nontaxable items in Massachusetts — after having done so here in 2024.

Last week, we heard from a reader who purchased the Sunday New York Times at his local Walgreens and was charged sales tax on it — 38 cents.

*MOUSE PRINT:

Walgreens receipt showing sales tax on NY Times purchase

Our consumer complained to the store manager, and also wrote to the company, the Massachusetts Attorney General’s office, and to us.

MrConsumer promptly went to his local Walgreens to make a test purchase of last Tuesday’s New York Times and the Boston Globe. The Times was indeed still being taxed but the Globe was not. According to the store cashier, however, both papers were taxed on Sunday, the same day our consumer spotted the error.

Under Massachusetts law, newspapers and magazines are exempt from sales tax.

We asked Walgreens how this latest sales tax error occurred, how many customers were affected, and how they were going to make refunds given that most people don’t save the receipt when buying a newspaper.

In a statement, the company said:

On November 7, a taxability update inadvertently caused newspapers sold at our Massachusetts stores to be incorrectly charged sales tax for a five-day period, from November 7 through November 11. We identified the cause and restored the correct point-of-sale tax treatment.

If customers believe they have been impacted and are now owed a sales tax refund, please contact 1-800-925-4733 for assistance. We ask that impacted customers who call this number have their receipt on hand to assist with the query.

Following a root-cause review, we have further refined our controls to help prevent a similar issue from occurring in the future. Walgreens does not profit from sales tax errors, as all taxes collected are remitted to the appropriate taxing authorities.

While the company doesn’t profit from tax overcharges, they are still taking money out of consumers’ pockets wrongfully. One would think that Walgreens could identify many of the affected purchasers and automatically make refunds to those customers who used their myWalgreens loyalty card.

As noted, two years ago we discovered Walgreens was charging sales tax on cookies and crackers here despite food being exempt from taxation in the state. [See original story.] The company apologized and took responsibility for an internal error that miscategorized these items as baked goods (which are sometimes taxed).

In addition, Walgreens has had repeated issues with charging the correct sales tax in the past. They were sued or called out for improperly charging tax on toilet paper in Pennsylvania in 2023, on COVID test kits in New York in 2022, on milk in Massachusetts in 2019, and on bottled water and certain unsweetened beverages in several Illinois areas in 2015 and 2017.

Let’s hope their new steps will prevent future incidents like these.

Share this story:

 


ADV
Updated every Monday!   Subscribe to free weekly newsletter.

Barilla “Made in Italy” Case Finally Decided

Four years ago, we told about some consumers who sued Barilla because despite the front of the package proclaiming “ITALY’S #1 BRAND OF PASTA,” their products are really made in the U.S.A. [See prior story.]

Barilla #1 pasta in Italy

A few weeks ago, the company asked the judge to find in their favor without a full trial. He granted their request. (See decision.)

The consumers’ lawyers presented evidence that over half of consumers seeing that claim thought the product’s ingredients were sourced from Italy. The company’s lawyers presented survey evidence that only 42% of consumers thought that. The judge found the front label claim to be ambiguous, and thus reasonable consumers might seek more information. And that additional information was on the side panel of every box:

*MOUSE PRINT:

Barilla Made in USA

Ultimately, the judge ruled for the company.

Some courts in other cases have said that a claim on the primary (front) panel of a product package governs, and that other explanatory language on the back cannot undo a misleading impression created by the claim on the front.

If you look at Barilla packages today, you will see that the #1 pasta in Italy claim is no longer there. The company said they planned this change before the lawsuit.

Barilla redesigned package

Share this story:

 


ADV
Updated every Monday!   Subscribe to free weekly newsletter.

Dollar General Sued for Overcharging by FTC and 20 States

Dollar GeneralLast week, the Federal Trade Commission and 20 states filed a massive lawsuit (see complaint) against Dollar General alleging widespread and prolonged overcharging.

Indeed, the suit says that between 2023 and 2026, Dollar General received at least 29,265 complaints alleging that the company “did not honor marked price.” The complaints came from all 48 states in which the company has stores.

Dollar General and its nearly 30,000 stores has a long history of run-ins with state inspectors. Between 2019 and 2026, they settled with six state AGs and paid over $6-million in penalties. Simply put, “Dollar General continues to advertise one price while charging a higher price at checkout.”

Dollar General adThe unusual aspect of this case is that the company’s overcharges are not simply the result of outdated shelf price labels not matching current prices in their checkout system, but also an allegation that some advertised items in their print circular rang up at higher prices too.

*MOUSE PRINT:

In one complaint, the consumer said,

“the weekly flyer . . . has advertised five for $5 with 2 l[iter] sodas. When I got up to the register[,] they were charging me $2.95 a[]piece. I explained about the sale and their statement was this is what their prices are.”

In 2026, undercover investigators from the FTC also visited stores in four states and made test purchases and then compared the price on the shelf to what they were actually charged. According to the complaint:

*MOUSE PRINT:

Every single undercover purchase resulted in Dollar General charging more at the register than the price advertised for multiple products:

During a January 16, 2026 undercover purchase at a Dollar General store in Cleveland, Ohio, 13 out of 58 items rang up with a price different than the price listed on a product label or shelf (an error rate of 22.4%). Of the 13 price inaccuracies, 5 were undercharges and 8 were overcharges, resulting in a net overcharge of $3.25.

In multiple instances, consumers who pointed out overcharges were brushed off and told they can either buy the item at the price on the register, or not buy it at all.

A third way that the company allegedly overcharged shoppers was by not honoring prices advertised on its website or smartphone app. Consumers have complained they clipped $5 off digital coupons in the app, but they were not honored at the checkout, or that an item was advertised online for a certain price, but they were charged more in the store. One consumer who visited 15+ stores was repeatedly told by employees they cannot override the price shown on the cash register.

In repeated state inspections, Dollar General often did not do well. For example, between 2023 and 2026, Dollar General failed 144 pricing audits and was fined over $175,000 and that was just in the state of Louisiana.

The lawsuit alleges widespread misrepresentation of product prices, overcharging, and deceptive trade practices. The FTC and the AGs seek monetary penalties, restitution, and an injunction to prevent similar overcharging in the future.

Dollar General issued a statement after the case was filed, in part saying:

Our goal is 100% accuracy between shelf and register prices in every store. …[but] occasional price discrepancies can occur. When that happens, our store teams are instructed, empowered, and expected to make things right for the customer.

The FTC staff also demanded a monetary amount that was untethered to – and orders of magnitude larger than – any realistic assessment of amounts attributable to pricing discrepancies. [We] offered an alternative, and in our view, more reasonable, manner of calculating potential settlement ranges. [R]ather than responding to our monetary counteroffer and allowing the negotiating process to continue, the FTC filed this lawsuit…

Share this story:

 


ADV